Justice Alex Mackay Ajiji has been criticized for a controversial murder case verdict at the high court in Kampala.
In a highly contentious criminal case before the High Court of Uganda at Kampala, Justice Alex Mackay Ajiji delivered a verdict that has sparked intense debate and scrutiny. The judgment, rendered in Criminal Session Case No: 0160F 2023, involved the prosecution of Muhumza Richard and Zanya Apollo for the murder of Ainebyoona Isaac.
According to the prosecution, the accused individuals, on the 15th day of May 2021 in Munyonyo, Makindye Division, Kampala District, allegedly caused the death of Ainebyoona Isaac with malice aforethought. The prosecution presented evidence suggesting that the deceased had been poisoned with carbofuran, an agricultural pesticide, leading to his demise.
However, the defense argued that the prosecution failed to meet the burden of proof required for conviction beyond a reasonable doubt. They pointed to inconsistencies in witness testimonies and raised doubts about the reliability of the forensic evidence presented.
In his judgment, Justice Ajiji highlighted the importance of the burden of proof resting solely on the prosecution and emphasized the standard of proof beyond a reasonable doubt. While acknowledging the gravity of the allegations, he underscored the need for meticulous evaluation of all evidence presented before reaching a verdict.
Critics of the judgment have raised concerns about the reliance on circumstantial evidence and the exclusion of alternative interpretations. They argue that Justice Ajiji’s decision may have been influenced by unsubstantiated rumours and speculation, rather than concrete scientific evidence.
The case has reignited discussions about the integrity of the judicial process and the adherence to fair trial standards. As the controversy continues to unfold, stakeholders are calling for a thorough review of the case and a reexamination of the evidence presented.
In the aftermath of the verdict, Justice Ajiji finds himself under scrutiny, with questions raised about the impartiality and soundness of his decision-making. The case serves as a reminder of the complexities inherent in criminal proceedings and the imperative of upholding the principles of justice and due process.
Renowned city lawyer Male Mabirizi took a bold step in protesting the appointment of Justice Alex Ajiji Mackay to the High Court.
In a letter addressed to the then Speaker of Parliament, Rt Hon Rebecca Kadaga, Mabirizi raised serious concerns regarding Justice Ajiji’s suitability for the position, citing issues related to his poor credibility.
Mabirizi, known for his fearless advocacy against perceived injustices, expressed reservations about Justice Ajiji’s appointment, questioning the judge’s track record and credibility.
We shall keep you updated on this matter.
